Should I trust Pmax for PPC
Is Google Performance Max driving new sales or claiming brand traffic? Test incrementality, spot inflated ROAS and balance PPC spending with SEO.
TL;DR: Google Performance Max can look like your best-performing channel while quietly billing you for traffic you already own. Across accounts we’ve reviewed, the majority of “brand” spend flowed through PMax instead of a cheap, dedicated brand campaign: clicks that would very likely have arrived free through organic search. That’s not growth. It’s double-paying for demand you created somewhere else. The real fix isn’t just tighter PPC settings; it’s investing in the channel PMax is feeding off: SEO.
The magic trick
Every magician relies on misdirection: make you look at the right hand so you miss what the left is doing. Performance Max runs the same play with your reporting dashboard.
PMax is Google’s black-box campaign type. You hand over budget, creative and a goal, and it serves ads across Search, Shopping, YouTube, Gmail, Discover and Maps, wherever its algorithm fancies. Then it reports back a glorious return on ad spend, and everyone nods approvingly in the monthly meeting.
Here’s the misdirection: a big share of that “return” isn’t new business. It’s demand you already had, dressed up as demand PMax created.
What the data actually showed
We looked at the search-terms reports behind two accounts. The pattern was the same in both.
In the first (a B2B equipment retailer), the company’s exact brand name drove 17 paid clicks (about £27, 3 conversions) through PMax in 14 days. The catch? That same brand term already ranked number one organically, and pulled 9 clicks for free over the identical period. So paid was scooping up roughly 65% of the brand-name clicks: traffic the business was, in effect, paying twice for. Those brand clicks converted at 17.6%, versus 3% for PMax overall, meaning a handful of nailed-on brand sales were quietly flattering the whole campaign’s average.
In the second (an industrial supplies brand), it was starker. Around £163 of brand-query spend ran through PMax in a fortnight, against just £11 in the actual brand search campaign. That’s roughly 94% of brand spend bypassing the cheapest possible route. The brand term was even being matched by three to six campaigns at once (PMax, Shopping, dynamic search and Brand all eligible), so the account was literally bidding against itself and inflating its own click costs.
Neither of these is a scandal of wasted thousands. The sums are small. The point is what they reveal: PMax reaches for the cheapest, highest-intent traffic first, and nothing is cheaper or higher-intent than someone Googling your name.
Why this inflates ROAS
Return on ad spend is a ratio, and ratios are easy to game when you get to choose the numerator.
People searching your brand were already coming to you. They typed your name; they had their wallet out. When PMax intercepts that click, the resulting sale lands in the paid column, even though you’d have won it for free. The algorithm didn’t create the customer. It stood in the doorway the customer was already walking through and took the credit.
Multiply that across every brand search, every “brand + location”, every “brand + support”, and PMax’s headline number swells with conversions it never truly earned. Your dashboard says “hero”. Your incremental growth says “meh”.
How to catch it: the incrementality test
You don’t have to take this on faith. Test it:
- Add brand exclusions to PMax so your own name routes to organic (or a cheap dedicated brand campaign).
- Watch what happens for 2 to 4 weeks. If organic brand clicks climb back up while total conversions hold steady, those paid clicks were never incremental. You just stopped paying for them.
- Run a brand-only holdout if you want the cleaner read.
If conversions genuinely drop, reinstate it; no harm done. If they hold, you’ve freed budget and exposed the trick.
Why you need less PPC and more SEO
Here’s the opinion part, and it follows directly from the numbers above.
If a meaningful chunk of your paid budget is harvesting demand rather than creating it, then you’re renting access to an audience you could own outright. Paid traffic stops the moment the budget does. It’s a tap: turn it off and the water stops instantly.
SEO is the opposite. It’s a well you dig once and draw from for years. The brand searches PMax is busy taking credit for? Something created that demand: content, reputation, word of mouth, organic visibility. That “something” is usually the work PPC quietly leans on and rarely gets billed for.
The uncomfortable truth for a lot of accounts: PPC is often measuring the success of your SEO and calling it its own. Shift even a slice of budget from harvesting existing demand to generating new demand (ranking for the questions your customers ask before they know your name), and you build an asset that compounds instead of a cost that resets to zero every month.
Less “pay to appear next to your own brand”. More “be the answer people find in the first place”.
But don’t set your PPC budget on fire
To be fair: PPC isn’t the villain, and this isn’t an argument to switch it all off. Paid search is brilliant for launches, genuinely competitive non-brand terms, testing messaging fast, and capturing high-intent demand SEO can’t reach yet. PMax has real uses. The problem isn’t the tool; it’s trusting its self-scored report card. Use paid for what’s genuinely incremental, and stop letting it invoice you for demand you already own.
Measure incrementality, not vanity ROAS. Then fund the channel that actually builds the demand, and watch which one is really carrying the account.
FAQ
Does Performance Max cannibalise organic traffic?
It can. PMax bids on brand and navigational searches by default, so clicks you’d win for free organically get served (and charged) as paid instead. Adding brand exclusions routes that traffic back to organic or a dedicated brand campaign.
How do I know if my PMax ROAS is inflated?
Check the search-terms data for brand queries running through PMax, then run a brand exclusion or holdout test. If organic recovers and total conversions hold when you exclude brand, that ROAS was inflated by non-incremental demand.
Should I stop using Performance Max?
No. Use it for genuinely incremental, non-brand demand. Just exclude your brand terms and judge it on incremental results, not its self-reported ROAS.
Is SEO better than PPC?
They do different jobs. PPC captures demand instantly but stops when the budget does; SEO compounds and creates the demand paid channels later harvest. For most brands over-invested in paid, shifting budget toward SEO improves long-term, lower-cost growth.
Key takeaways: PMax often claims credit for brand demand you already own; small brand-spend leaks reveal a big attribution problem; test incrementality with brand exclusions or a holdout; and rebalance budget toward SEO, the channel that actually creates the demand paid ads harvest.